Integrity at the corporate level is totally dead 25 July 2011Posted by splait in Annoyances (me), Annoyances (others), corruption, Criminals, entitlement, Grrrrrrrrrr!, Integrity, Lack of Integrity.
Tags: Atlanta Public Schools, Beverly Hall, Madoff, Murdoch, Rupert Murdoch
Corporate officers, especially at the CEO, CFO, COO, President, and COtB levels get paid the big bucks. For many years now, I have had a great many problems with how much they get paid, but that’s another point altogether different from what I really want to say here.
I’m pretty sure that, at least when I worked in Corporate America, the people who ran the companies were responsible for the actions that their employees took, no matter what. Of course, they were always responsible for the good stuff, the stuff that made their shareholders money. However, what ever happened to being responsible for the bad stuff?
It is interesting to hear Rupert Murdoch and his son claim that they are not responsible for their company’s current woes. I’m pretty sure that the people who tapped the phones of others illegally as they worked for the company were being paid by the company for their work. In my mind, that makes the people who run the company responsible for those illegal actions – under all circumstances.
So, fast forward back through time* to a year or so ago in Atlanta, where we first hear of a cheating scandal being exposed in the Atlanta Public School system here. The woman who ran the system, Ms. Beverly Hall, claimed (and continues to claim) she was innocent of the charges. Today, despite the evidence against her, she continues to claim that she was unaware of the problems that were going on during her watch and that she is not responsible.
Here’s the first paragraph of a press release you can still find online with her picture smiling back at us on the first page:
“When Dr. Beverly L. Hall became the 15th appointed superintendent of the Atlanta Public Schools (APS) on July 1, 1999, she promised to transform the district into a world-class school system, using nationally proven reform models, facility upgrades and business operations redesign. Under her leadership, standardized test scores have risen, aging facilities have been renovated and a new blueprint for business operations is being implemented. The district’s vision is that APS will be one of the nation’s highest performing urban school systems, where 90 percent of its ninth- graders graduate from high school in four years ready for success in college or career.”
The good news is, she actually managed to accomplish a great number of those goals, as stated.
Part of the bad news is that she did it while teachers and administrators created a conspiracy of manipulation of grades and changing of test scores.
The rest of the bad news is that the local political establishment ignored the amazing results she was turning in year after year as a sign that something might be terribly wrong (shades of Bernie Madoff!), and the people who are going to pay for this are the students and their parents, as well as students and parents of the coming school years.
Ironically, when Googling “beverly hall superintendent”, the link right after the link to the press release is:
The person in charge of an organization, corporation, event, or anything else is ultimately responsible for the good AND bad stuff that comes down on their watch. We can forgive them if we wish, but that is our choice. In the old days, a Japanese man was expected to commit hari-kari if the organization he ran (it was almost always a “he”) was dishonored by anyone in the organization. Today, the Japanese only expect the COO to resign.
In the US, they often do resign, but, if they are a member of Congress or a major corporation, they not only get Platinum Parachutes, but they often get more money running some other company or, in the case of the government, they get full pensions and insurance benefits, even if they only served one term.
I went into the wrong line of work.